Custom Lettering Critique

Hi everyone,

I’m currently working on a custom lettering project for a logotype ("ADAMO") and I would love to get some critical eyes from this community.

I’m mainly looking for feedback on optical adjustments, letter spacing, and anything else that catches your attention—especially what doesn't work or needs adjustment. Any critiques, micro-adjustment suggestions, or reference points would be greatly appreciated. 

Thank you in advance!



Comments

  • SCarewe
    SCarewe Posts: 140
    edited October 30
    The way the side of A and M wiggle is inconsistent, even with the M itself. I would look for a uniform approach here. The top flare on the A join isn't found in the M at the top, only on the bottom. Either keep it or leave it off.

    The M is unbalanced: internal white space left is bigger than right. It's also inclined more on the left than on the right.

    The D top half of the curve is squashed and generally the stroke thickness is uneven.

    Generally, stroke thicknesses are not balanced, so the contrast is pretty wonky. See also the second bar in the M: its flow on the left side doesn't match the flow of its right side.

    Overall very rough, but there's a general idea. If you can reign this in clearly and polish the curves more, this could end up looking great.
  • John Hudson
    John Hudson Posts: 3,946
    The difference in feel between the organic A M and the geometric D O adds to the lack of cohesion. I would try to find a way to make the D and O more organic, but probably only after resolving the A and M further.
  • Yves Michel
    Yves Michel Posts: 252
    Is Adamo related to the Belgian famous singer? He sold 80 millions records throughout the world.
    Or to the Canadian Winery (same origin of the name).
    In both cases, I'd go for organic! ;)
  • ficod
    ficod Posts: 8
    edited November 2
    Thanks to all of you for the insightful critiques! I will try my best to incorporate them tough I'm quite puzzled as a first reaction. Maybe a mix of language barrier and an amateurish type awareness.

    My main concerns are keeping the design simple and not far from the original while doing all sorts of adjustments. I don't want to look defensive here, I am open to everything that can improve this design... but the fact is it was already approved and I took the initiative to refine it with the help of you wonderful folks here. 

    • I see lacking some coherence in stroke widths and it needs work in that direction. so balance and corrections in the M internal spacing should be the first things I will address.
    • Making D and O more organic would be great but as I said I have no big ideas on that without doing major redesign. 

    Adamo is not related to the singer... although he was originally from the same area (Ragusa) of this "Adamo".

  • ficod
    ficod Posts: 8
    I tried some small adjustments, it seems a bit better overall to my eyes.