Color font issue (random scaling of glyphs) in Word and PowerPoint

Options

Hi, I’ve made an extended colorfont (Latin Extended glyph set incl. kerning) with Glyphs which works well in design apps and browsers. When I’m in Word (16.46 on Mac OS 10.15) or PowerPoint and start typing, I get strange seemingly random scaling of some glyphs (see images) very frequently, sometimes all flips to the right size once I hit return to go to the next line. When I paste text all works well. I’ve generated the font as ttf and otf, with COLR/CPAL and/or SVG, all fonts appear to have the same issue in Word and PowerPoint.


Does that ring any bells?

@Jens Kutilek RoboChrome and the same issue happens there when I generate a ttf with COLR/CPAL. Only when I generate a ttf with SVG does the font perform as expected!

Thanks
Martin

Comments

  • Thomas Phinney
    Thomas Phinney Posts: 2,807
    Options
    Does the strange scaling go away when you generate it as a plain non-color font?
  • Martin Wenzel
    Options
    Yes, the issue only occurs in the colorfont version of the ttf or otf.
    I'm wondering if the negative left & right side bearings (the underline element exceeds the width on either side) have anything to do with the glitch.
  • Peter Constable
    Options
    What flavour of colour font? COLR? SVG? 'sbix'?
  • Martin Wenzel
    Martin Wenzel Posts: 48
    edited March 2021
    Options
    Hi @Peter Constable the issue occurs with the COLR version only. I have made many test but have not yet come to a conclusion why MS Office on Mac is misinterpreting the data. Something I did find out though is that Word does not like it at all when the width of a glyph is exceeded.
    (We don't need sbix, we're only interested in vector based color fonts)
  • Martin Wenzel
    Options
    @Peter Constable I'll gladly supply a demo font if you're interested
  • Peter Constable
    Options
    @Martin Wenzel I'll follow up with you in a private message.
  • Martin Wenzel
    Options
    @Peter Constable thank you, we'd very much appreciate that. You can get in touch with me at supertype.de or via twitter (supertype_de).
    Ideally there is a solution that would allow users to exchange Word documents across platforms without having to switch fonts (from OpenType COLR on Windows to OpenType SVG on MacOS).
  • Felipe Sanches
    Options
    @Peter Constable & @Martin Wenzel, if you figured out what was the problem, I'd be interested in implementing a FontBakery check to automatically detect and report it.
  • Martin Wenzel
    Options
    @Felipe Sanches I have not yet figured it out but @Peter Constable is having a look at the issue.
  • bBox type
    bBox type Posts: 1
    Options
    Hi @Martin Wenzel
    Any news on this topic? Same happens here ...
    Thank you! Anja 
  • Martin Wenzel
    Options
    Hi @bBox type, I had some exchange with @Peter Constable but have not yet gotten an answer how this issue can be solved.
  • Martin Wenzel
    Options
    Hi @Peter Constable any update on the color font issue I had reported here? The bug persists in the latest update of MS Word on Mac (16.49, 21050901)
  • Peter Constable
    Options
    I reported this to engineers for Office. They were working on some higher priority issues, and then would be working on getting DWriteCore code converged for different platforms, at which point they could investigate this.
  • Martin Wenzel
    Options
    @Peter Constable thanks for the update, much appreciated.
  • petrusenik
    Options
    Hello to everyone! I am joining to tell you that I have the same problem, but only for Powerpoint. MS Word does work fine.
    Do you have some kind of update for it?
  • Peter Constable
    Options
    @petrusenik Can you please clarify what OS/version and what versions of PowerPoint and Word you're using.