Hinting for layered fonts?

Nick Shinn
Posts: 2,286
Is it a good idea to hint layered fonts?
On the one hand, they will be used together for display purposes, so it’s not really necessary because of the large size, and might even cause strange effects when one layer isn’t snapped to the same alignment as another, when a full page is viewed on screen.
…But on the other hand, if someone wants to use one of the fonts singly, hinting would sharpen things up.
To muddy the waters, it appears that Adobe InDesign performs its own hinting on my iMac screen, “bolding” fonts with unhinted stem widths, thereby obscuring decorative details. (This doesn’t occur in the OS application Pages.)

Left: “Inline” Font with no Stem Hints: InDesign fuzzes up the inline. Right: With Stem hints, InDesign renders more sharply.
On the one hand, they will be used together for display purposes, so it’s not really necessary because of the large size, and might even cause strange effects when one layer isn’t snapped to the same alignment as another, when a full page is viewed on screen.
…But on the other hand, if someone wants to use one of the fonts singly, hinting would sharpen things up.
To muddy the waters, it appears that Adobe InDesign performs its own hinting on my iMac screen, “bolding” fonts with unhinted stem widths, thereby obscuring decorative details. (This doesn’t occur in the OS application Pages.)

Left: “Inline” Font with no Stem Hints: InDesign fuzzes up the inline. Right: With Stem hints, InDesign renders more sharply.
0
Comments
-
Nick, I think what is happening is the exact reverse of what you wrote. Pages is using macOS rendering, which always autohints outlines (and ignores the original hinting if any).
InDesign uses the hinting built into your font... so in the absence of hints, yes, InDesign’s rendering of this college-outline effect gets worse and key distances are not explicitly maintained. But that isn’t autohinting, I don’t think.3 -
Thanks Thomas. My brain hurts.
1
Categories
- All Categories
- 46 Introductions
- 3.8K Typeface Design
- 480 Type Design Critiques
- 558 Type Design Software
- 1.1K Type Design Technique & Theory
- 647 Type Business
- 837 Font Technology
- 29 Punchcutting
- 513 Typography
- 119 Type Education
- 319 Type History
- 75 Type Resources
- 110 Lettering and Calligraphy
- 31 Lettering Critiques
- 79 Lettering Technique & Theory
- 540 Announcements
- 88 Events
- 112 Job Postings
- 168 Type Releases
- 171 Miscellaneous News
- 275 About TypeDrawers
- 53 TypeDrawers Announcements
- 120 Suggestions and Bug Reports