fonteditors.com: comparing font editors (feedback welcome)
Erwin Denissen
Posts: 326
Most of you know me from FontCreator, so let me say this first: fonteditors.com is made by High-Logic, and every page on the site says so.
For years I’ve been annoyed by “best font editor” lists. They recommend software nobody maintains anymore, quote old prices, get the platforms wrong, and almost never say where their information comes from. That includes what they write about FontCreator. So we built the comparison we wanted to point people to:
Right now it compares 11 font editors on 81 features, from FontForge and Glyphr Studio to Glyphs, FontLab, RoboFont, Fontra and FontCreator.
What we tried to do differently:
- Every value shows where it comes from, a link to the page or a note that the developer told us, and the date it was checked. If we couldn’t verify something, it says “not verified”. A feature only counts as not supported when a source says so, or when the editor’s documentation covers it in depth and doesn’t mention it. In that case the note says which documentation we read.
- FontCreator gets the same rules and the same scoring formula as every other editor.
- The chooser lets you pick what you want to make, your platform, budget, scripts and the features you need. Editors that don’t fit stay in the list, with the reason why.
- The scoring formula, the feature definitions and the inclusion criteria are all on the methodology page.
We used AI for both the development and the research, and that’s exactly why I wanted every value to show where it comes from. AI makes mistakes, and so do we. This way they’re easy to spot and fix.
fonteditors.com is the first of a few comparison sites. fontmanagers.com is coming soon, and fontgenerators.com later. Same approach, different kind of font software.
For now, I’d really like your feedback. Many of you know Glyphs, FontLab, RoboFont, Fontra and the others much better than I do. If something is wrong, outdated, missing or unfair, please tell me, here or through the site. The same goes for editors that are actively maintained and meet the criteria but aren’t listed yet. And if you think the methodology itself is wrong, I want to hear that too.
I’m not trying to convince anyone that FontCreator is the best choice. The goal is to help people find the editor that suits them best, even when that’s a competitor.
Erwin
5
Comments
-
Hi Erwin,
You forgot DTL Foundry Master.
DTL OTMaster also has font editing capabilities and is the best for font post-production.1 -
The DTL tools are an interesting case, because they have always been a suite of tools, rather than a single, does-everything editor.I use OTMaster regularly, but have mostly not used other DTL tools. I also use other tools, like VOLT and MathFont, for specific tasks within a multi-tool workflow and production chain.1
-
Thanks, Sami. Both are on the site now, under Other font tools. DTL FoundryMaster is in “Font editors we follow”: DTL says version 10.3 is available for testing, but there’s no release date or download yet. We’ll look at it again once it’s out.OTMaster is in a new section, “Production and specialist tools”, for tools that do one part of the work next to a font editor, such as editing finished fonts, OpenType layout and hinting:
https://fonteditors.com/other-font-tools/#production0 -
Thanks, John, that’s exactly how we’ve tried to handle it now.
The comparison stays limited to font editors, and “Production and specialist tools” lists OTMaster, VOLT, VTT, AFDKO, FontGoggles, Font Bakery and Fontspector.
MathFont isn’t there yet, as I have no information about it. Is it publicly available? If so, I’ll add it.
0 -
MathFont is what shows up in the topbar of the Microsoft MathFontEditor when it is running. It is publicly available in the sense that if you track down the right person to ask at Microsoft, they will give you a copy of it; which might not be sufficiently public for your list. It is a stand-alone tool for visually editing the content of an OpenType MATH table. It has no source format that I can determine, but works directly on the table; which is sort of terrifying.4
-
Great project! I suggest of course to make it available on Github under a libre license for direct community contributions
Some suggestions of actively maintained editors; I can list unmaintained ones if you wish
https://runebender.org
https://counterpunch.space
https://fontbob.com
https://fontstruct.com0 -
Also https://shift.graphics/ . In an AI-era these things will proliferate... ("In the future everyone will have their own font editor for fifteen minutes, before they get bored of developing it and move onto something else.")4
-
Thanks, Dave!For now I’m keeping the site in-house, but every value links to its source, and anyone can send a correction through the link on each editor page.From your list, FontStruct is in the comparison, and FontBob and Counterpunch are on our list of editors we follow. Runebender is on it now too; I’d been looking at the old Linebender repository. New editors join the comparison after two years:
https://fonteditors.com/other-font-tools/#watching
And yes, please send the unmaintained ones.0 -
Thanks, Simon, for the tip!
Shift is now on our list of editors we’re following.
And yes, I suspect we’ll see many more! We want to give new projects visibility from the start, while reserving the full comparison for editors with an established track record. Our current requirement is two years of public availability and ongoing maintenance.
It’s certainly not a judgment of their quality. Some newcomers may well turn out to be better than established editors. We just want to be careful about what we can reliably recommend.
1 -
I think watching new tools develop for a period of time before adding them to the comparison is an excellent idea. I have seen many font editor projects begin and fizzle over the years, so waiting for one to mature before adding it is wise. I also love that the two-year period you have chosen is so completely at odds with ‘I used Claude code to make this half-finished thing on the weekend and demand that you take it seriously and praise me for it.’7
-
-
Thanks Dave.
TruFont and Prototypo are already in the "Other font tools" list, marked discontinued and shut down.
MFEK is on the list of editors we follow: its last release is still the 2023 beta, and the commits since then only keep it building. Metapolator wasn't on the list yet. It never got past "not yet released", and its last commit was in July 2018, so it goes in with the discontinued editors.1 -
MFEK was Fred Brennan’s project. The GitHub repository is still live, but the MFEK website is down.@Dave Crossland, any insight if someone is looking after this since Fred’s death?0
-
No it died with him. I don't think anyone else ever used it.2
Categories
- All Categories
- 47 Introductions
- 4K Typeface Design
- 505 Type Design Critiques
- 597 Type Design Software
- 1.1K Type Design Technique & Theory
- 681 Type Business
- 912 Font Technology
- 29 Punchcutting
- 547 Typography
- 131 Type Education
- 334 Type History
- 82 Type Resources
- 114 Lettering and Calligraphy
- 33 Lettering Critiques
- 81 Lettering Technique & Theory
- 592 Announcements
- 102 Events
- 119 Job Postings
- 181 Type Releases
- 189 Miscellaneous News
- 270 About TypeDrawers
- 54 TypeDrawers Announcements
- 114 Suggestions and Bug Reports

