Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Christian Thalmann

About

Username
Christian Thalmann
Joined
Visits
2,533
Last Active
Roles
Member
Points
296
Posts
723
  • Re: Start Grotesque

    BTW, if you're feeling adventurous, you could even add a few more blackletter-style quirks, such as a /P with a full-height body and a descender, /H and /K with overhead arches, lowercase-style /N and /M, etc...  maybe as a third export font, so as not to weigh down your default font.
  • Re: Sailboat – a grotesque

    I rather like its flavor and its backstory. First impressions:
    • Lowercase spacing is much too loose; hence the unexpected behavior at text sizes.
    • The rounds often seem too «pointy», i.e. diamond-shaped, in particular in /O and /c.
    • Does the stroke width oscillate in a quadrupole pattern, i.e. become broader in the diagonals, in the round strokes?
    • Widths feel a bit inconsistent, with e.g. /M/R/a/m on the wide end and /G/H/L/T on the narrow end.
    • /a feels a bit droopy, foot of /t timid, head of /f short.
    • Serif on /7 feels out of character to me.
  • Re: Replace ß by smallcap eszett or smallcap ss?

    It can't be that bad if the Duden as been using it on its cover...

    The only reason I can think of not to use the cap ß is if it's badly designed (e.g., not instantly readable or disharmonious with the other letters), which is unfortunately rather often the case. Luckily, this is a problem that type designers can freely address by themselves.  :smile:
  • Re: Replace ß by smallcap eszett or smallcap ss?

    As for «predictability»: I would argue that switching fonts will generally change the appearance of a given text more drastically than exchanging SS with ẞ... and while using SS for ẞ can cause loss of information, sticking to ẞ never does. After all, if the user typed ß before capitalization, they meant ß rather than ss. Anyone who can read ß can also read ẞ without hesitation — if not, the ẞ is badly designed.

    But then again, I'm not a typographer.
  • Re: Replace ß by smallcap eszett or smallcap ss?

    A historical practice is not necessarily a logical practice. The practice of writing capital ä as Ä overruled Ae since it's more consistent. Similarly, ẞ should now overrule SS when capitalizing ß, since it's more consistent. We have no obligation to stick to past mistakes.